научный журнал
вестник Санкт-Петербургского государственного
института культуры
RUS| ENG

The reception of Vernet’s Orientalist paintings by art criticism in the 1830s–1840s

  • Annotation
  • Authors
  • List of references

Horace Vernet (1789–1863), one of the prominent French artists of his time, achieved his greatest success at the time of the July Monarchy (1830–1848), thanks to the patronage of King Louis-Philippe. Like many of his contemporaries, H. Vernet was fascinated by the exotic of the East. Fast every year one or more of his Orientalist paintings were exposed at the Salons. His battle canvases, commissioned by the King, recorded not only various stages of the French conquest of Algeria, but also the realities of life in North Africa. Vernet’s fascination for Eastern culture was reflected in his treatment of biblical subjects and genre scenes as well. This article is devoted to the study of perception of Vernet’s Orientalist paintings by art critics. It bases on the texts of critical reviews of the Salons. Well-known writers, poets, such as T. Gautier, P. Mérimée, Ch. Baudelaire and others functioned as critics. Many of them were warm supporters of romanticism, while classicism remained in demand, among others. The eclecticism inherent in the creative method of H. Vernet, which can be perceived as an expression of the «juste milieu» in the arts, was often met with disdain by reviewers of the Salons. At the same time, H. Vernet’s innovative techniques, including the Arabization of the Bible, ran into frank misunderstanding.

  • Гончарова Татьяна Николаевна
  • Durande A. Joseph, Carle et Horace Vernet. Correspondance et biographies. Paris: J. Hetzel, 1864. 360.
  • Brintseva A. A. Creativity of Horace Vernet in the mirror of criticism. Art History. 2011. 1/2, 548–564 (in Russ.).
  • Renaudeau C. Horace Vernet (1789–1863): chronologie et catalogue raisonné de l’oeuvre peint. Thèse de doctorat sous la dir. de Bruno Foucart. Lille: ANRT, 2000. 850.
  • Baudelaire-Dufaÿs Ch. Salon de 1845. Paris: Jules Labitte, 1845. 72.
  • Turchin V. S. From the history of Western European art criticism of the XVIII-XIX centuries. Moscow: Publ. house of Moscow State Univ., 1987. 368 (in Russ.).
  • Yakovleva T. Yu. Formation of literary and artistic journalism in France in the 19th century. URL: http://19v- euro-lit.niv.ru/19v-euro-lit/yakovleva-stanovlenie- zhurnalistiki/zhurnalistika-pervoj-poloviny-xix-veka. htm (accessed: Jan. 15.2022) (in Russ.).
  • Brintseva A. A. The canvas of Horace Vernet «The Taking of Abd-el-Kader» as a pictorial document of the French conquest of Algeria. Historical, philosophical, political and legal sciences, cultural studies and art history: questions of theory and practice. Tambov, 2014. 10 (3), pp. 44–47 (in Russ.).
  • Dayot A. Les Vernet. Joseph-Carle-Horace. Paris: Armand Magnier, 1898. 238.
  • Rosenthal L. Du Romantisme au Réalisme: essai sur l’évolution de la peinture en France de 1830 à 1848. Paris: Macula, 1987. 448.
  • Gautier T. Salon de 1839. La Presse. 1839. Mai 18.
  • Gautier T. Salon de 1845. La Presse. 1845. Mar. 18.
  • Baudelaire-Dufaÿs Ch. Salon de 1846. Paris: Michel Lévy frères, 1846. 132.
  • Thoré T. Salon de 1845. Le Constitutionnel. 1845. Févr. 25, No 56.
  • Thoré T. Salon de 1845. Le Constitutionnel. 1845. Mar. 18, No 77.
  • Thoré T. Salon de 1846. Le Constitutionnel. 1846. Avr. 30, No 120.
  • Planche G. Le Salon de 1846. La Peinture. Revue des Deux Mondes. 1846. 14 (2), 283–299.
  • Delécluze E.-J. Salon de 1845. Aperçu général – M. Horace Vernet. Journal des débats politiques et littéraires. 1845. Mar. 18.
  • Mérimée P. Salon de 1839. Revue des Deux Mondes. 1839. 18 (1), 83–103.
  • Vernet H. Des rapports qui existent entre le costume des anciens Hébreux et celui des Arabes modernes. L’Illustration. 1848. 10 (259), févr. 12, 370–372.
  • Tardieu A. Salon de 1831. Annales du Musée et de l’École moderne des beaux-arts. Paris: Chez Pillet aîné, 1831. 304.
  • Landon Ch.-P. Annales du Musée et de l’École des Beaux-arts, Salon de 1835. Paris, 1835. 88.
  • Lenormant Ch. De l’école française en 1835. Salon annuel. Revue des Deux Mondes. 1835. 2 (2). P. 167–209.
  • Arrigon J. L. Les années romantiques de Balzac, d’après des documents nouveaux et inédits. Paris: Perrin, 1927. 297.
  • Delécluze E.-J. Exposition au Luxembourg: M. H. Vernet. L’Artiste. 1831. 1, 21–24.
  • Planche G. Salon de 1831. Paris: Pinard, 1831. 304 p. 26. Houssay A. Salon de 1847. L’Artiste. 1847. 9, 33–35. 27. Thoré T. Le Salon de 1847, précédé d’une lettre à Firmin Barrion. Paris: Alliance des arts, 1847. 204.
  • Planche G. Le Salon de 1847. La Peinture. Revue des Deux Mondes. 1847. 18 (2), 354–366.
  • Curmer L. Salon de 1843. Les Beaux-Arts. 1843. 1, 25–29.
  • Peisse L. Le Salon de 1843. Tableaux d’histoire. Revue des Deux Mondes. 1843. 2 (2). P. 255–273.
  • Peisse L. Le Salon de 1844. Revue des Deux Mondes. 1844. 6 (2), 338–365.
  • Gautier T. Salon de 1834. Théophile Gautier. URL: http://www.theophilegautier.fr/wp-content/ uploads/2010/06/Salon-de-1834.pdf (accessed: Jan. 17.2022).
  • Planche G. Études sur l’école française (1831– 1852). Peinture et sculpture. Paris : Michel Lévy frères, 1855. 1, 281–357.
  • Anonyme. Le Salon de 1836. Peinture. L’Artiste. 1836. 11, 75–79.
Authors: Goncharova Tatiana
Рубрика: Искусствоведение
Pages: 142-149
УДК: 75-051(=133.1)”1789/1863”:7.03(5)
DOI: 10.30725/2619-0303-2022-4-142-149
Keywords: Horace Vernet, July Monarchy, Salons, Orientalism, art criticism, artistic directions, «juste milieu»
График выхода номеров
№1
март

1 декабря - заканчивается прием работ

25 февраля - сдача номера в печать

Выход в свет - март

№2
июнь

1 марта - заканчивается прием работ

25 мая - сдача номера в печать

Выход в свет - июнь

№3
сентябрь

1 июня - заканчивается прием работ

25 августа - сдача номера в печать

Выход в свет - сентябрь

№4
декабрь

1 сентября - заканчивается прием работ

25 ноября - сдача номера в печать

Выход в свет - декабрь